MikeT99
New Member
And I agree with you, thus also agreeing and disagreeing with @handzI agree and disagree. I do think while one is actually composing it is to a large extent 'by ear' or feeling. But I would argue the one who's studied music theory (traditional and non-traditional) and is familiar with a lot of the literature (traditional and non-traditional) will be quicker to write what their ear hears or what they feel because of that previous study. That's all I'm saying.
I too believe composition is a three-fold process: feel, that you can tie to an emotional level; improvisation, even with pencil and paper, but on a systematic and permanently analyzed form; and intelectual, where you make use of all the tools and devices theory, in all its forms, has given you. If I could reorder in some kind of chronological way, I guess intelect and feel would come up first, leading to the creative process of the actual composition.